Do Orthotics Help Knee Pain? What the Research Shows
|
|
Time to read 10 min
|
|
Time to read 10 min
Reviewed by Carla Benson, DPM
Carla Benson is a podiatrist with experience treating a wide range of foot and ankle conditions. She is also a medical and health writer with published research on lower-extremity conditions.
Knee pain is a very common problem, and it can range from minor discomfort that's only a mild inconvenience to debilitating pain that interferes with daily life. For some people, knee pain may present as a deep, dull ache that persists no matter if you're active or inactive. Alternatively, it can come in the form of sharp, stabbing pain that flares up when you stand up, walk or climb stairs. In order to best address knee pain, it's important to understand the cause. Mild knee pain may go away on its own, but severe and persistent pain should be evaluated by a healthcare professional who can make a diagnosis and recommend a treatment plan.
In some cases, orthotics may be helpful for knee pain, especially when combined with other lifestyle changes and treatments. For many individuals, orthotics like Dr. Scholl's® Knee All-Day Pain Relief Orthotics can provide noticeable relief.
There has been some research into the effectiveness of orthotics for certain types of knee pain. Orthotics aren't always recommended for every type of knee pain.
|
Knee Condition |
What the Research Shows |
Can Orthotics Help? |
| Knee osteoarthritis (OA) |
Mixed results for reducing knee pain |
May help some people, but results vary |
| Patellofemoral pain syndrome (PFPS), commonly known as runner's knee |
Promising results for improving knee function |
May improve function, but not always pain |
| Iliotibial band syndrome (ITBS) |
Very limited direct research |
May be considered based on individual foot mechanics |
When it comes to research on using orthotics for osteoarthritis in the knees, the findings are mixed. Since everyone is different and responds differently to various therapies, it's often best to seek the advice of a healthcare provider. Your doctor may recommend trying orthotics for pain relief. Since orthotics are a non-invasive therapy, they may be recommended before considering other types of treatments, such as medications or surgery.
There have been some promising results in studies that focus on orthotics for patellofemoral pain syndrome, which is also known as runner's knee. In one study conducted as a randomized trial, researchers found the devices provided some short-term improvements. However, it's important to note that the orthotics weren't more effective than physiotherapy. In another study, researchers found that orthotics enhanced knee function, making it easier to participate in sports and other recreational activities. Still, the reduction in knee pain wasn't statistically significant.
Unfortunately, there is very limited research and evidence on using orthotics for Iliotibial band syndrome (ITBS). If your healthcare professional suggests trying orthotics, the recommendation may not be because of strong evidence but rather as an individualized approach to addressing factors that may contribute to your symptoms.
Your feet serve as the base of your body's kinetic chain. Any movement that begins with the feet affects the joints of the lower body. This includes the joints in your ankles, knees, hips and lower back. If you have issues, such as flat feet or overpronation, you may be out of balance and causing additional stress on certain areas of the lower body. This may contribute to knee pain.
Certain orthotics may help relieve knee pain in some people because they can alter lower-extremity mechanics and redistribute or reduce impact on the feet when you run, walk and jump. Orthotics are not always effective for all people with knee pain, but some people find that the right shoe insert can make a difference.
If you're trying to figure out whether orthotics will help your knee pain and you're unable to or don't wish to speak to a healthcare provider, you might consider an over-the-counter shoe insert. These are affordable options that are easy to purchase in stores and online. There are many different options, depending on your needs and preferences. One option to consider is Dr. Scholl's® Advanced Pain Relief Insoles. These easy-to-use shoe inserts provide ultimate cushioning and support to protect the joints of the lower body.
Custom orthotics may be an option for people who don't receive adequate relief from over-the-counter treatments and at-home care. Your doctor may recommend custom orthotics if they think this type of device may be beneficial for your condition. Your doctor will likely conduct a physical examination and check different issues in order to determine what's causing your knee pain. They may also conduct tests. If they determine that custom orthotics are right for you, they will take measurements, perform scans, or make a mold of your feet to create them.
It’s important to understand that orthotics do not always provide a complete solution for knee pain. Your provider may recommend that you incorporate other therapies into your pain relief plan to better address knee pain. These may include cold therapy, bracing, over-the-counter pain relievers, physical therapy and adjustments to your exercise routine. Your doctor may want to evaluate you regularly and monitor your progress to determine if you require more advanced medical treatment.
There are several different types of healthcare specialists who can treat knee pain. You may want to ask your primary care provider to refer you to the appropriate specialist. Seeing a podiatrist is often helpful when the cause of your knee pain seems to be directly related to your feet. Orthopedists and sports medicine doctors are frequently the preferred choice for medical situations involving injuries or conditions that affect the bones, joints, muscles, or other tissues in and around the knee.
During your visit, the doctor will likely perform a physical examination of the knee. They may take X-rays or order other imaging tests if needed. They will also likely ask you questions about the type of pain you're experiencing, including how often it happens, which movements make it worse, and how long you've had the pain. Be sure to mention any patterns you notice since this may help determine what's causing the pain. The treatment methods prescribed or recommended to you may include orthotics, physical therapy, medication, activity changes, corticosteroid injections, or any combination of these approaches.
Mild to moderate knee pain doesn't always require medical intervention. You may be able to address your knee pain by combining orthotics with lifestyle changes and at-home care. However, if your symptoms don't improve or they become worse, it's best to contact your healthcare provider. It's also important to seek medical care if your pain is severe, it started suddenly following an injury or accident, or if you have a fever, severe swelling, or your knee is red and hot to the touch. Don't hesitate to contact your doctor if you're concerned or if you have questions.
Orthotics can help some people with knee pain, but results vary by individual and condition. Research shows mixed findings depending on the specific knee problem. For conditions like patellofemoral pain syndrome, studies have found orthotics may improve knee function and make daily activities easier. For knee osteoarthritis, results are mixed, with some people experiencing relief while others do not. Since orthotics alter lower-extremity mechanics and redistribute impact, they may reduce stress on the knee joint. Some individuals experience noticeable relief when using orthotics as part of a comprehensive treatment plan that includes other therapies.
Patellofemoral pain syndrome, also known as runner's knee, tends to show the most promising response to orthotics based on current research. Studies indicate that orthotics can enhance knee function for some people with this condition, making it easier to participate in sports and recreational activities. However, it’s not known if orthotics help with pain related to this condition. Knee osteoarthritis may also respond to orthotics in some cases, though results vary widely. When knee pain is related to foot mechanics issues like flat feet or overpronation, orthotics may provide relief by improving alignment and reducing stress on the knee joint.
Ask your healthcare provider if you’re unsure about which type of orthotic to choose for knee pain. You might consider starting with over-the-counter orthotics if you want an affordable, accessible option. These insoles are easy to purchase in stores and online without a prescription. If over-the-counter options don't provide adequate relief after a reasonable trial period, consult your healthcare provider about custom orthotics. They require a prescription and the provider will need to take scans or molds of your feet. You will also need to wait while the custom orthotics are made. They cost more but may be beneficial for persistent pain or specific biomechanical issues that standard insoles cannot address.
How long it takes for orthotics to help knee pain varies by individual and the underlying cause of knee pain. Some research on patellofemoral pain syndrome found short-term improvements, suggesting benefits may appear within weeks. However, your body may need time to adjust to the biomechanical changes that orthotics create. You should give orthotics a fair trial of several weeks while monitoring your symptoms. If you don't notice any improvement after consistent use, or if your pain worsens, contact your healthcare provider to discuss whether orthotics are the right approach for your specific condition.
Yes, orthotics may help runner's knee for some individuals. Runner’s knee is the common term for the medical condition patellofemoral pain syndrome. Research shows promising results for this condition, with studies finding that orthotics may improve knee function and help people who participate in sports or other leisure activities. While the improvement in knee function has been notable in studies, the reduction in actual pain levels wasn't always statistically significant. This means orthotics may improve your ability to move and exercise even if they don't completely eliminate pain. Combining orthotics with other treatments like physical therapy may provide better overall results.
Orthotics aren't recommended for every type of knee pain, and their effectiveness varies depending on the underlying cause. If your knee pain results from acute injury, infection, or conditions unrelated to foot mechanics, orthotics may not be the appropriate treatment. Always consult a healthcare professional to determine if orthotics are suitable for your specific knee condition.
Your feet serve as the base of your body's kinetic chain, meaning any movement that begins with the feet affects the joints throughout the lower body, including the knees, hips and lower back. If you have foot issues such as flat feet or overpronation, you may be out of balance, causing additional stress on certain areas of the lower body. This imbalance can contribute to knee pain. Orthotics may help by improving foot function and redistributing or reducing impact on the feet when you run, walk and jump. This in turn can reduce stress on the knee joint.
Seek medical care if your knee pain is severe, if it started suddenly following an injury or accident, or if you have concerning symptoms like fever, severe swelling, or if your knee is red and hot to the touch. These signs may indicate a serious condition requiring immediate medical attention. Also see a doctor if mild to moderate knee pain doesn't improve with at-home care and orthotics, or if your symptoms become worse over time. A healthcare professional can perform a physical examination, order imaging tests if needed, and determine the underlying cause of your pain. They can then recommend appropriate treatment.
Orthotics do not always provide a complete solution for knee pain on their own. Your healthcare provider may recommend incorporating other therapies into your pain relief plan, including cold therapy, bracing, over-the-counter pain relievers, physical therapy and adjustments to your exercise routine. Combining orthotics with lifestyle changes and at-home care often provides better results than relying on a single treatment approach. Your doctor may want to evaluate you regularly and monitor your progress to determine if you require more advanced medical treatment or if your current combination of therapies is working effectively.
Seeing a podiatrist is often helpful when the cause of your knee pain seems to be directly related to your feet. Podiatrists specialize in foot and ankle conditions. They understand how foot mechanics affect the entire lower body. Orthopedists and sports medicine doctors are frequently the preferred choice for medical situations involving injuries or conditions that affect the bones, joints, ligaments, muscles and other tissues. You may want to ask your primary care provider to refer you to the appropriate specialist based on your symptoms and medical history.
Sources:
[1] https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6921534/
[2] https://www.bmj.com/content/342/bmj.d2912
[3] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18952682/
[4] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35721679/
[5] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40700173/
[6] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18487594/
[7] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36536460/
[8] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24357961/
[9] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0268003322000717
[10] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35429692/
[11] https://www.jospt.org/doi/10.2519/jospt.2019.0302